Holds your interest throughout.
Added 7/27/2009
In a country village, in England, in 1800, Silas Marner is a deacon, a leader in his village church and is dating a pretty young woman. A rival wants the girl who Silas Marner is dating, and so sets up Silas Marner and falsely accuses him of the crime. Everyone believes the liar and they kick Silas out of the church. Everyone of any prominence is a member of the village church and will no longer buy Silas Marner's fabrics. So he must move far away and start over. He is bitter toward the church people who wronged him, and he never attends church again. Money is his only friend and security. Another scoundrel comes into the life of Silas to do him another wrong. Yet, a baby-toddler-girl comes into his life, who gives him joy. There is a lot of story in this story that keeps on happening till the end. Some heartwarming moments.
Filmed on location; you really feel like you are there, back in 1800 in England. All the technical aspects of the film are fine.
Contrary to a reviewer below, you are able to follow a good story without having read the book. The reviewer likely means there is more story in the book, which this film misses, and we have to work harder than we should have to work, to figure out what is happening. There is a lot of room for improvement. This film should be re-made. I give my suggestions for improvement under the "comment"-button below; though with spoilers; so you do not want to read it until after watching the film.
1 out of 2 people found this helpful.
|
Excellent Interpretation of a Classic
Added 5/11/2009
Being very familiar with the story from 'rote' reading in English Literature classes did nothing to lessen the wonder of seeing the story played out by an excellent casting of actors that bought the characters to life with care and sensitivity to the period and the people.
I would recommend this video to anyone reading the book as illumination of the time, the place and the people.
I would recommend this video to anyone trying to understand the human condition in a time of stratification, the cost of choices made that effect human lives, and the quiet generosity of those punished by a society in which they have no voice.
0 out of 0 people found this helpful.
|
Silas Marner
Added 4/21/2009
I read this book for the first time a couple of years ago. I didn't really think that all of the pertinent information in the book could be included in a 90 minute movie...but I can think of nothing left out.
And the fact that it stays true to the book was important to me, also. Very touching, very believable acting.
Interesting and informative George Eliot biography bonus feature is also included.
1 out of 1 people found this helpful.
|
Faithful Adaptation with Good Acting
Added 8/18/2008
This 1985 BBC production of Silas Marner is pretty loyal to Mary Ann Evan's (i.e. George Eliot's) novel "Silas Marner: The Weaver of Raveloe." I had to read the novel "Silas Marner" in 10th grade English. While I do not remember all of the minor details of the novel, I do not recall this BBC production missing any of the major characters or elements of plot.
I also have always enjoyed watching videos starring Ben Kingsley (ex: Oliver Twist, Gandhi, Schindler's List). While Silas Marner seldom speaks for the first half of the film, Ben Kingsley does a good job portraying Silas Marner's essential character traits (as described in the novel).
Now, unlike BBC's Daniel Deronda or Middlemarch, which have an aspect ratio of 16:9, Silas Marner (like The Mill on the Floss and Adam Bede) has an aspect ratio of 4:3. This in unfortunate, but it does not make the film too difficult to view.
Also, unlike many of Charles Dickens' works, many of Mary Ann Evan's novels have NOT been made into films by other companies (ex: Hallmark or Masterpiece Theatre). Therefore, viewers have very few others choices except for the BBC version, which I think is adequate.
1 out of 1 people found this helpful.
|
Silas Marner DVD Review
Added 6/14/2008
Silas Marner, with Ben Kingsley, is an excellent movie with fine acting and dialog, and realistic settings. In my opinion, the musical score by Carl Davis is rather soapaoperatic and not very satisfying.
1 out of 2 people found this helpful.
|
Holds your interest throughout.
Added 7/27/2009
In a country village, in England, in 1800, Silas Marner is a deacon, a leader in his village church and is dating a pretty young woman. A rival wants the girl who Silas Marner is dating, and so sets up Silas Marner and falsely accuses him of the crime. Everyone believes the liar and they kick Silas out of the church. Everyone of any prominence is a member of the village church and will no longer buy Silas Marner's fabrics. So he must move far away and start over. He is bitter toward the church people who wronged him, and he never attends church again. Money is his only friend and security. Another scoundrel comes into the life of Silas to do him another wrong. Yet, a baby-toddler-girl comes into his life, who gives him joy. There is a lot of story in this story that keeps on happening till the end. Some heartwarming moments.
Filmed on location; you really feel like you are there, back in 1800 in England. All the technical aspects of the film are fine.
Contrary to a reviewer below, you are able to follow a good story without having read the book. The reviewer likely means there is more story in the book, which this film misses, and we have to work harder than we should have to work, to figure out what is happening. There is a lot of room for improvement. This film should be re-made. I give my suggestions for improvement under the "comment"-button below; though with spoilers; so you do not want to read it until after watching the film.
1 out of 2 people found this helpful.
|
Excellent Interpretation of a Classic
Added 5/11/2009
Being very familiar with the story from 'rote' reading in English Literature classes did nothing to lessen the wonder of seeing the story played out by an excellent casting of actors that bought the characters to life with care and sensitivity to the period and the people.
I would recommend this video to anyone reading the book as illumination of the time, the place and the people.
I would recommend this video to anyone trying to understand the human condition in a time of stratification, the cost of choices made that effect human lives, and the quiet generosity of those punished by a society in which they have no voice.
0 out of 0 people found this helpful.
|
Silas Marner
Added 4/21/2009
I read this book for the first time a couple of years ago. I didn't really think that all of the pertinent information in the book could be included in a 90 minute movie...but I can think of nothing left out.
And the fact that it stays true to the book was important to me, also. Very touching, very believable acting.
Interesting and informative George Eliot biography bonus feature is also included.
1 out of 1 people found this helpful.
|
