Review Of The 1956 Epic 'Giant' (2003 WB)
Added 10/24/2009
1.) The audio is pretty good (some of the music is so famous such that anyone born and raised in Texas in the
past 50 years probably knows it without even realizing it) but the picture image quality has not fared so
well. Another reviewer theorized that the DVD was made from a 3rd or 4th generation copy. About that I don't
know but the result is that some of the imagery is not as good as it should be. (Example : In the opening
shot a watering pond for cattle (in Texas it's known as a 'tank') is shown. The color is faded and not clear
making one wonder how the opening scene looked to theater audiences 50 years ago.)
2.) I think that some of the acting is overdone and the attempt to 'act like Texans' causes some of the scenes
to be almost comical (you have to 'stand back' and think about how the scenes strike you). Now, having said
that, I will also say that some of the scenes are so 'classic' that they make up for shortcomings of other
scenes. (Example: When James Dean shows-up covered in oil after his first well comes in, it seems exactly
what anyone would do when everyone else figured that he would 'lose-his-shirt'.)
The overall 'look-and-feel' of 'Giant' is so much larger-than-life that its strenghts overcome its shortcomings.
If heroic music gets you excited, and the thought of a horizon that stretches further than seems reasonable
makes you want to get in your car and 'head west', then you've got to see 'Giant'.
- Paul Nix (Oct 2009)
0 out of 0 people found this helpful.
|
Jim's Review
Added 10/24/2009
The item was in perfect shape and the vendor was very quick in getting it to me.
0 out of 0 people found this helpful.
|
Beautiful CLASSIC movie
Added 10/12/2009
Elizabeth Taylor is STUNNING. This movie is captivating, you won't be able to turn away. Great story and perfect characters
0 out of 0 people found this helpful.
|
"Bick, you shoulda shot that fella a long time ago. Now he's too rich to kill."
Added 9/8/2009
In GIANT, the last entry of James Dean's motion picture trilogy, he portrays Jeff Rink, an oil rig worker who acquires a piece of land, sets out on his own, strikes oil and eventually becomes a petroleum multi-millionaire. On the night of the triumphant opening of his magnificent airport/hotel complex some years later, Rink boozes himself into oblivion and shocks the attending crowd with an incoherent podium speech. (Note: Dean's inebriated ramblings were dubbed by Nick Adams.)
Here, Dean enthusiastically chews scenery and everything in sight; thus he's the best-remembered part of a story that's primarily about the Benedicts, 'Bick' (Rock Hudson) and Leslie (Elizabeth Taylor), and the contrasts between their old money elegance and the nouveau riche vulgarity of Dean's.
A sweeping Edna Ferber melodrama as big as the Lone Star State itself that's directed by George Stevens, "Giant" unfolds more slowly than most newer films. Despite great scenery, cinematography, sets, a strong cast and fine music score, because of its leisurely pace this epic hasn't held up as well (in my opinion) as Dean's penultimate effort, REBEL WITHOUT A CAUSE (1955).
Recommended:
Liz Taylor's meaty performance as 'Maggie the Cat' in the screen adaptation of Tennessee Williams' CAT ON THE HOT TIN ROOF (1958) may be the pinnacle of her legendary career. Co-stars Paul Newman (as inattentive husband 'Brick') and Burl Ives (as the unforgettable 'Big Daddy').
Parenthetical number preceding title is a 1 to 10 imdb user poll rating.
(7.7) Giant) (1956) - Elizabeth Taylor/Rock Hudson/James Dean/Carroll Baker/Jane Withers/Chill Wills/Mercedes McCambridge/Dennis Hopper/Sal Mineo/Rod Taylor/Earl Holliman/Paul Fix/Alexander Scourby/Sheb Wooley (uncredited: Kermit Maynard/Nick Adams-voice)
0 out of 0 people found this helpful.
|
The Movie "Giant"
Added 8/30/2009
The movie "Giant" is merely the best from start to finish!
The screen play, acting, direction and photography is set aside
for none to compare!
To witness James Dean's transition from youth to middle age
was a masterpiece!
0 out of 0 people found this helpful.
|
Review Of The 1956 Epic 'Giant' (2003 WB)
Added 10/24/2009
1.) The audio is pretty good (some of the music is so famous such that anyone born and raised in Texas in the
past 50 years probably knows it without even realizing it) but the picture image quality has not fared so
well. Another reviewer theorized that the DVD was made from a 3rd or 4th generation copy. About that I don't
know but the result is that some of the imagery is not as good as it should be. (Example : In the opening
shot a watering pond for cattle (in Texas it's known as a 'tank') is shown. The color is faded and not clear
making one wonder how the opening scene looked to theater audiences 50 years ago.)
2.) I think that some of the acting is overdone and the attempt to 'act like Texans' causes some of the scenes
to be almost comical (you have to 'stand back' and think about how the scenes strike you). Now, having said
that, I will also say that some of the scenes are so 'classic' that they make up for shortcomings of other
scenes. (Example: When James Dean shows-up covered in oil after his first well comes in, it seems exactly
what anyone would do when everyone else figured that he would 'lose-his-shirt'.)
The overall 'look-and-feel' of 'Giant' is so much larger-than-life that its strenghts overcome its shortcomings.
If heroic music gets you excited, and the thought of a horizon that stretches further than seems reasonable
makes you want to get in your car and 'head west', then you've got to see 'Giant'.
- Paul Nix (Oct 2009)
0 out of 0 people found this helpful.
|
Jim's Review
Added 10/24/2009
The item was in perfect shape and the vendor was very quick in getting it to me.
0 out of 0 people found this helpful.
|
Beautiful CLASSIC movie
Added 10/12/2009
Elizabeth Taylor is STUNNING. This movie is captivating, you won't be able to turn away. Great story and perfect characters
0 out of 0 people found this helpful.
|