Discover
In the wake of Shannan Gilbert’s funeral, family lawyer John Ray presents Josh and Rachel with confidential testimony that implicates a local doctor and Oak Beach resident in the death of the young escort. Yet, a critical questions remains unanswered, is Shannan’s death connected to the four escorts discovered at Gilgo Beach? In order to find out, Josh and Rachel return to the secluded Oak Beach community where one family despite threats from several residents is willing to speak out. Meanwhile, rumors surface that the murders at Gilgo Beach are linked to a serial murder case in Atlantic City, which took place less than five years prior and offers eerie similarities. They decide to pay a visit to the City of Sin.
Original Release
11/19/2016
US Release
11/19/2016
Cast
| Name | Character |
|---|
| Hugh Auslander | Self - Kim's Ex-Husband |
| Jeffrey Blitz | Self - Atlantic County Prosecutor 1985 - 2007 |
| Peter Brendt | Self - Amateur Profiler |
| Richard Dormer | Self - Former Suffolk County Police Commissioner |
| Vernon Geberth | Self - Author, Practical Homicide Investigation |
| Mari Gilbert | Self - Shannan's Mother |
| Shannan Gilbert | Self - Murder Victim |
| Tricia Griffith | Self - Host, True Crime Radio |
| Peter Hackett | Self - Former Head of Suffolk County Emergency Medical Services |
| Jim Hutchins | Self - Ret. Vice Squad Captain, Atlantic City PD |
Directors
Writers
Cast
| Name | Character |
|---|
| Hugh Auslander | Self - Kim's Ex-Husband |
| Jeffrey Blitz | Self - Atlantic County Prosecutor 1985 - 2007 |
| Peter Brendt | Self - Amateur Profiler |
| Richard Dormer | Self - Former Suffolk County Police Commissioner |
| Vernon Geberth | Self - Author, Practical Homicide Investigation |
| Mari Gilbert | Self - Shannan's Mother |
| Shannan Gilbert | Self - Murder Victim |
| Tricia Griffith | Self - Host, True Crime Radio |
| Peter Hackett | Self - Former Head of Suffolk County Emergency Medical Services |
| Jim Hutchins | Self - Ret. Vice Squad Captain, Atlantic City PD |
| Sara Karnes | Self - Maureen's Friend |
| Robert Kolker | Self - Author, Lost Girls |
| Terry Oleson | Self - Golden Key Motel Handyman |
| Kenna Quinet | Self - Author, The Missing Missing |
| John Ray | Gilbert Family Lawyer |
| Joe Scalise Jr. | Self - Oak Beach Resident |
| Joe Scalise | Self - Oak Beach Resident |
| Khalil White | Self - Jessica Taylor's Boyfriend |
| Joshua Zeman | Self - Filmmaker |
| Rachel Mills | Self - Filmmaker |
Producers
| Name | Role |
|---|
| Rachel Mills | Executive Producer |
| Alex Gibney | Executive Producer |
| Brad Hebert | Executive Producer |
| Stacey Offman | Executive Producer |
| Richard Perello | Executive Producer |
| Jeremy Batchelor | Producer |
| Caitlin Colford | Producer |
| Jeana Dill | Producer |
Editors
